The Express Tribune reported on 8 November 2026 that the Auditor General of Pakistan (AGP) has found irregularities of Rs25.7 billion in the Benazir Income Support Programme (BISP) for the financial year 2024-25.
The story was first reported by The News on 24 June 2026. The 8 November story is a fresh publication of the same AGP Audit Report 2025-26 — it is not a new audit. The figures, the audit year and the findings are the same.
At the centre of the audit are weaknesses in spouse-data profiling in BISP-MIS. The largest share of the exposure comes from beneficiaries recorded without a spouse CNIC. The audit also found payments to government employees, pensioners or their spouses despite a cabinet ban, payments to vehicle owners above the allowed limit, duplicate Taleemi Wazaif stipends and wrongful enrolments linked to multiple PMT scores.
BISP has responded to the findings. It says the duplicate spouse-CNIC cases are suggested discrepancies for rectification, not verified fraud. The Departmental Accounts Committee (DAC) has directed immediate blocking of the flagged beneficiaries and the start of recovery operations.
BISP Audit Rs25.7 Billion Irregularities at a Glance
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Audit report | Auditor General of Pakistan, Audit Report 2025-26 |
| Audit period | FY2024-25 |
| Total irregularities | Rs25.7 billion |
| Total cases | 601,850 |
| Key finding | Spouse CNIC missing in 596,252 cases |
| Government employees paid | 12,078 cases — Rs515.712 million |
| Vehicle ownership cases | 1,719 cases — Rs69.744 million |
| DAC direction | Immediate blocking and recovery; MoU with Pakistan Bait-ul-Mal |
| BISP clarification | Suggested discrepancies, not verified fraud |
What the Audit Found — Breakdown of BISP Irregularities
The headline figure of Rs25.7 billion is the combined value of two spouse-CNIC problems: 596,252 beneficiaries without a spouse CNIC (Rs25,459.960 million) and 5,598 cases where one spouse CNIC was linked to several beneficiaries (Rs239.035 million). Together they come to Rs25,698.995 million across 601,850 cases.
The audit also reported other separate findings. These are not added to the Rs25.7 billion headline. They are separate observations in the same report.
| Finding | Cases | Amount (Rs million) |
|---|---|---|
| Spouse CNIC missing | 596,252 | 25,459.960 |
| Duplicate spouse CNIC | 5,598 | 239.035 |
| Government employees, pensioners or spouses paid | 12,078 | 515.712 |
| Multiple PMT scores — wrongful enrolments | 18,964 | 533.536 |
| Vehicle ownership above threshold | 1,719 | 69.744 |
| Taleemi Wazaif duplicate stipends | 165 schools | 17.690 |
| Abroad travel cases | 261 | 13.041 |
Source: Express Tribune, 8 November 2026; The News, 24 June 2026.
Inclusion and exclusion errors
The audit also measured how well BISP was reaching the right households. It found an inclusion error of 6.8% against a benchmark of 5%, and an exclusion error of 13.27% against a permissible limit of 10%. The programme had 10.02 million active households.
| Measure | Audit finding | Benchmark / permissible limit |
|---|---|---|
| Inclusion error | 6.8% | 5% |
| Exclusion error | 13.27% | 10% |

The Spouse-CNIC Problem Explained
The audit found two related spouse-CNIC problems.
First, 596,252 beneficiaries were recorded without any spouse CNIC. Payments of Rs25,459.960 million were made in these cases. Without a spouse CNIC, BISP cannot properly check whether a household is receiving more than one benefit, or whether a spouse is a government employee or pensioner.
Second, the audit pointed out 5,598 cases in which one spouse CNIC was linked to more than one female beneficiary — in some cases, up to seven. The amount involved was Rs239.035 million.
These are the two groups that make up the Rs25.7 billion headline. BISP’s clarification on the 5,598 cases is set out in the response section below.
Government Employees Paid Despite the Ban
The audit found that 12,078 government employees, pensioners or their spouses received Rs515.712 million under the Unconditional Cash Transfer (UCT) programme during FY2024-25. This was despite a federal cabinet directive of 24 December 2019 that excluded civil servants and their spouses from BISP.
| Group | Cases | Amount (Rs million) |
|---|---|---|
| Active government employees, Grades 1-16 | 673 | 25.20 |
| Employees in Grade 17 | 8 | 0.09 |
| Pensioners, spouses and other categories | — | — (see note) |
| Total | 12,078 | 515.712 |
The News published a more detailed breakdown of the 12,078 cases. The category counts in that breakdown do not reconcile to 12,078, so only the headline total and the two grade-specific rows above are reproduced here.
These payments are separate from the Rs24 billion disclosure reported in October 2026, which covered 140,488 government employees over the period 2019-2025. The difference is explained later in this article.
Vehicles and Other Findings
Vehicle ownership
The audit found that 1,719 beneficiaries who owned motor vehicles above the prescribed threshold continued to receive UCT payments worth Rs69.744 million. The audit reviewed vehicle registrations only in Islamabad — 275,000 registrations were test-checked. Registrations in other regions were not checked.
Multiple PMT scores
The audit found 97,179 cases of multiple PMT scores. These led to 18,964 wrongful enrolments worth Rs533.536 million. A PMT score is used to decide whether a household is poor enough to qualify for BISP.
Taleemi Wazaif duplicate stipends
The audit found duplicate stipends worth Rs17.690 million under Taleemi Wazaif, involving 165 Bait-ul-Mal schools.
BISP employees registered as students
The audit also found 278 BISP employees registered as students. The amount involved in these cases is not stated in this article because the published sources conflict on the figure. One source prints Rs202.546 million and the other prints Rs2.546 million. Until the correct figure is confirmed, no amount should be used.
Abroad travel cases
The audit found 261 beneficiaries who had travelled abroad but continued to receive payments worth Rs13.041 million.
BISP’s Response and Clarification
BISP issued a clarification after the audit was first reported. It was published on 26 June 2026.
BISP said the 5,598 spouse-CNIC cases are suggested discrepancies for rectification, not verified fraud. It said one family is eligible for only one benefit, and no payment is made without NADRA profiling. BISP also said its data was recertified in June 2025, and that its database covers 38.7 million household records.
The clarification does not cancel the audit findings. It adds balance: the audit pointed out weaknesses in data and profiling, and BISP says the cases need to be checked and corrected rather than treated as proven fraud.
Source: BISP clarification reproduced by Wayout News, 26 June 2026.
What the DAC Ordered
The Departmental Accounts Committee (DAC) directed action on the audit findings.
| Action | Detail |
|---|---|
| Immediate blocking | Flagged beneficiaries to be blocked from further payments |
| Recovery | Recovery operations initiated for wrongly paid amounts |
| MoU with Pakistan Bait-ul-Mal | API integration to prevent duplicate benefits across programmes |
| Data clarification from NADRA | BISP to obtain clarifications on spouse and profiling data |
| Independent spouse verification | BISP-MIS to verify spouse records independently |
| Conduct inquiries | Inquiries against responsible officials |
| Physical verification | Physical verification of 10-15% of beneficiaries |
No recovery total for this FY2024-25 audit has been confirmed since June 2026. This article does not print a recovery figure for this audit.
How This Differs from the Rs24 Billion October Disclosure
There is a separate BISP disclosure that should not be mixed with this audit. In October 2026, the National Assembly was told about Rs24 billion in irregularities over the period 2019-2025, involving 140,488 government employees. That disclosure also reported Rs710 million recovered. That recovery figure belongs only to the October disclosure — it is not the recovery total for this FY2024-25 audit.
| Item | FY2024-25 AGP audit (this article) | October 2026 National Assembly disclosure |
|---|---|---|
| Amount | Rs25.7 billion | Rs24 billion |
| Period | FY2024-25 | 2019-2025 |
| Government employees involved | 12,078 | 140,488 |
| Recovery | Not confirmed in this audit | Rs710 million recovered |
| Source | AGP Audit Report 2025-26 | National Assembly disclosure |
For the different disclosure, see our separate Rs24 billion BISP irregularities report.
What It Means for Beneficiaries
For most eligible families, this audit does not mean their payments have stopped. The audit is about people who should not have been paid, or who were paid because of data errors. It is not a decision to stop BISP for eligible families.
If you are eligible and your record is correct, your payment should continue as normal. If your record has a problem — for example, a missing spouse CNIC — BISP may ask you to update it.
How to check your BISP status via 8171
- Open the SMS app on your mobile phone.
- Type your 13-digit CNIC number, without dashes.
- Send it to 8171.
- You will receive a reply about your eligibility and payment status.
- If the reply asks you to visit a BISP office or update your record, follow the instructions in the message.
- Do not pay anyone to check your status. The 8171 service is free.
You can also read our BISP registration and programme information guide.
Frequently Asked Questions About the BISP Audit
Is this a new audit?
No. The audit was first reported by The News on 24 June 2026. The Express Tribune published a fresh story on the same AGP Audit Report 2025-26 on 8 November 2026. It is the same report, not a new audit.
What did the audit find?
The audit found irregularities of Rs25.7 billion across 601,850 cases in FY2024-25. Most of this — Rs25.46 billion — involved beneficiaries recorded without a spouse CNIC. The audit also found payments to government employees, pensioners or their spouses, vehicle owners above the threshold, and other data problems.
How much money is involved in the spouse-CNIC problem?
Rs25,698.995 million, or about Rs25.7 billion. This is made up of Rs25,459.960 million for 596,252 beneficiaries without a spouse CNIC, and Rs239.035 million for 5,598 cases where one spouse CNIC was linked to several beneficiaries.
Were the 5,598 duplicate cases proven fraud?
No. BISP says these are suggested discrepancies for rectification, not verified fraud. One family is eligible for only one benefit, and BISP says no payment is made without NADRA profiling.
How many government employees received BISP payments?
The audit found 12,078 government employees, pensioners or their spouses received Rs515.712 million under the UCT programme in FY2024-25, despite a federal cabinet directive of 24 December 2019 excluding civil servants and their spouses.
What did the DAC order?
The DAC directed immediate blocking of the flagged beneficiaries and initiated recovery operations. It also directed BISP to sign an MoU with Pakistan Bait-ul-Mal for API integration and to get data clarifications from NADRA.
How much money has been recovered from this audit?
No recovery total for this FY2024-25 audit has been confirmed since June 2026. Do not confuse this with the Rs710 million recovered in the separate Rs24 billion October disclosure, which covers a different period (2019-2025) and different cases.
Will eligible families lose their BISP payments?
No. The audit does not mean payments have stopped for eligible families. It is about people who should not have been paid, or who were paid because of data errors. If your record is correct, your payment should continue as normal.
How can I check my BISP status?
Send your 13-digit CNIC number by SMS to 8171. You will receive a reply about your eligibility and payment status. The service is free.
What is the difference between the Rs25.7 billion audit and the Rs24 billion disclosure?
The Rs25.7 billion figure is from the AGP Audit Report 2025-26 for FY2024-25, first reported in June 2026. The Rs24 billion figure is from a separate National Assembly disclosure in October 2026, covering 2019-2025 and involving 140,488 government employees. They are two different disclosures and should not be mixed.
Disclaimer
This article is based on the AGP Audit Report 2025-26 for FY2024-25, as reported by The News on 24 June 2026 and the Express Tribune on 8 November 2026, and on BISP’s clarification published on 26 June 2026.
Figures are reported as published in those sources. Where sources conflict — for example, on the amount involved in the 278 BISP employee-student cases — no amount is printed in this article.
This article is for information only. It is not an official BISP statement. For the latest updates on your payment or eligibility, check via 8171 or visit the nearest BISP office.
Sources
- The News, 24 June 2026 — AGP audit of BISP for FY2024-25
- The News, 26 June 2026 — BISP clarification
- Express Tribune, 8 November 2026 — “BISP audit reveals Rs25.7 billion irregularities”
- Express Tribune, 24 October 2026 — Separate Rs24 billion National Assembly disclosure




